Serava

Questions a council chair should ask a manager

By Serava · 5 min read

co-ownership counciltourism residencetransparencyproperty managementowner's money

When a manager comes before a co-ownership council, the difference between a polished presentation and a serious firm shows in the questions asked. Here are the ones a chair should put, and what a good answer looks like, seen from an operator's day-to-day work. No law here, only operations.

Where does the money from stays go?

This is the first question, and it is often enough to sort candidates. Between a guest's payment and the transfer to the owner, the money sits somewhere: ask where, in which account, in whose name, and who can touch it.

A good answer is precise and dull: it describes an account dedicated to rental funds, separate from the manager's operating accounts, and the same flow for every owner.

A vague answer, such as "everything is handled in our system", is not an answer. The system does not say where the money sleeps between two transfers.

What will I see each month, and in what form?

Ask for a sample monthly statement, anonymised, before any decision. Not a sales mock-up: a real statement, as an owner receives it.

A serious statement reads line by line: each stay, what the guest paid, what the platform took, the tourist tax, the property preparation fee (forfait de préparation du logement), the management fees, and the net amount paid out. If a line cannot be understood in one sentence, have it explained.

The right follow-up question: "if I find a gap between my statement and my transfer, who answers me, and how fast?"

Who decides what about my property?

A manager works in the property all season: it lets in guests, service providers, sometimes tradespeople. Ask for the rules before, not after.

Three points to put in writing: who sets prices and by what method, who can commit spending on the property and up to what level without the owner's consent, and how the owner books the weeks they keep for themselves.

Here too, precision is a good sign. A manager who answers "we always sort it out" is describing an organisation that depends on people, not on rules.

Who is on site, and what happens on a Saturday breakdown?

A tourism residence lives to the rhythm of changeovers: arrivals and departures are packed into a few hours, the same for everyone. Ask who is physically present on those days, and how many units each person looks after.

Then put the concrete scenario: a heating failure on a school-holiday Saturday, property occupied. Who is told, who goes in, who decides, who pays, and what does the owner see afterwards?

The answer says everything about the firm: a real organisation has already lived through that Saturday and tells you how it went, without improvising.

How will I know the residence is running well?

Beyond their own unit, a chair needs an overall view: is the residence well kept, are the common areas respected, are guests properly managed?

Ask what the manager commits to report collectively: a regular update to the co-ownership council, a named contact for the building manager (syndic), and a clear rule on guests respecting the co-ownership rules.

A manager who only wants to talk to each owner separately, never to the collective body, is giving up a valuable ally for a residence that works.

What happens if it goes wrong?

Nobody likes to ask this at the first meeting. Yet it is the most useful question: how does the relationship end?

Ask for the length of commitment, the exit terms, and what is handed back to the owner on departure: stay history, contacts, property documents, photos. A manager confident in its service has no need to keep clients by making it hard to leave.

And ask for references: other owners, a building manager, a co-ownership council already working with them. Calling them takes an hour and saves dozens.

For owners who live abroad

If you live in the United Kingdom or elsewhere, the same questions matter even more: you will rarely be on site to check. Ask in which language statements and reports are sent, and who answers you, in your language, when something goes wrong.

Frequently asked questions

In what order should these questions be asked? Money first, statement second. If those two answers are clear, the rest of the discussion rests on solid ground. If they are vague, the rest does not matter.

Should the answers be in writing? Yes, at least for money, decision rules and exit terms. What is written before signing avoids difficult conversations afterwards.

Can a chair ask these questions for the whole residence? Each owner remains free to choose. But a council that asks the right questions once, for everyone, saves each owner from redoing the work alone, and puts every candidate in front of the same questionnaire.

How do you compare two managers who both answer well? On evidence: a real statement rather than a promise, a visit to units already managed, references actually called. With equal pitches, the firm that shows beats the firm that tells.

Take stock of your residence

Altitude 2100 is Serava's letter for owners in French tourism residences: legal and tax deadlines, explainers, owners' questions. Sign up at serava-group.com.

Do you chair the co-ownership council or the owners' association of a tourism residence? Ask for a free audit of your residence: classification, lease deadlines, operator obligations, calendar. Answer within 48 hours of a written request, with no commitment.

Behind Serava is EDN Gestion: an agency holding the French professional licence for property management (carte G) issued by the Chamber of Commerce, with a financial guarantee of €150,000 from SOCAF.

Altitude 2100

La lettre des propriétaires en montagne

Une fois par mois : la saison, le marché locatif, la réglementation, les résidences de tourisme et ce qui change pour votre appartement.

En vous inscrivant, vous acceptez de recevoir Altitude 2100, la lettre mensuelle de Serava, et des informations sur ses services de gestion locative. Un email de confirmation vous est envoyé. Désinscription en un clic dans chaque envoi.